Last week was the best market week we've seen in many months. What changed, if anything, to produce the buoyancy? There are a number of reasonable explanations, and a few popular explanations.
1. The chairman of Citibank declared they were making money. That pronouncement from an internal memo, conveniently leaked, strikes me a blantant effort to inject "confidence" where none has been warranted. Citibank has always made money on an operating basis. Borrowing at 1% and lending at 5% is profitable. There is the "minor" issue of losing value in the collateral by the billions that was not addressed.
2. Technical oversold conditions. Each day tens of millions of shares change hands for non fundamental reasons. For the past year, it has been a profitable trade to be short. Sell on the bounce, cover on the dip, rinse and repeat. Last week the market reached a very oversold condition. Shorts covered, whether true buyers emerged is still questionable.
3. Bernanke made noises that the recession was going to end, as one headline stated, "shortly." Another trumpeted that the Fed chairman feared the political will was lacking. You decide.
Watch CBS Videos Online
Monday, March 16, 2009
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
His Lips Are Moving?
This seems like it could be the Jeopardy Show answer to, "how do you know a banker is lying?"
The 300+ dow bounce yesterday was certainly appreciated, even overdue after the relentless reality of the past weeks. I lament however the reasons the talking heads give for this gasp as if it were an all clear signal. Citibank CEO Vikram Pandit yesterday said his bank is doing swimmingly. They even made money in the first two months of the year, which as far as I can tell from the details he gave, he may have found a twenty dollar bill in the parking garage which went straight to the bottom line.
That the chairman of the erstwhile largest money center bank would state, "we are making money," without disclosure of how much the balance sheet was impaired in the same time period is a travesty. Putting that twenty in your pocket and ignoring the detail that you lost your wallet with five hundred dollars in it is hardly full disclosure.
Bushido, the samurai code of conduct, The Way of the Warrior had seven virtues: Rectitude, Courage, Benevolence, Respect, Honesty, Honor, and Loyalty. Might I suggest the next congressional hearing begin there?
John Barnyak
President
The 300+ dow bounce yesterday was certainly appreciated, even overdue after the relentless reality of the past weeks. I lament however the reasons the talking heads give for this gasp as if it were an all clear signal. Citibank CEO Vikram Pandit yesterday said his bank is doing swimmingly. They even made money in the first two months of the year, which as far as I can tell from the details he gave, he may have found a twenty dollar bill in the parking garage which went straight to the bottom line.
That the chairman of the erstwhile largest money center bank would state, "we are making money," without disclosure of how much the balance sheet was impaired in the same time period is a travesty. Putting that twenty in your pocket and ignoring the detail that you lost your wallet with five hundred dollars in it is hardly full disclosure.
Bushido, the samurai code of conduct, The Way of the Warrior had seven virtues: Rectitude, Courage, Benevolence, Respect, Honesty, Honor, and Loyalty. Might I suggest the next congressional hearing begin there?
John Barnyak
President
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
It's not the end of the world, but you can see it from here
I've been crunching numbers since last October. In another time and culture it might be throwing the I Ching or divining entrails, but here, it's formulae. Warren Buffet warns against kids with calculators, but I'm old and have a pencil, so maybe this will work.
Personally I think we still haven't seen the bottom of the market for a few reasons. Perhaps the major one being that CNBC is still on the air. Today, Nouriel Roubini opined that the S&P will see 600 by October. After a nine hundred point drop in the past eighteen months, another seventy in seven months seems like child's play. Another ten percent? Bring it on!
Considering how prescient Mr. Roubini has been in this economic debacle finding our projections relatively close seems a comforting confirmation of my own work. Below are my reasons for throwing my dart at 600.
1. I project earnings next year near $50 for the S&P 500. Goldman Sachs suggests $40 so I am not the most pessimistic.
2. Currently inflation is essentially zero.
3. Typically in a deep recession the PE ratio troughs in the high single digits however inflation impacts future earnings present value so I expect the market PE to more likely settle in the area of 12x earnings.
4. 12 times 50 is....600. Voila
It is so critical for the policy makers to get the banking system sorted out. Without that, it will remain difficult to move ahead.
What will be difficult is that bear market rallys will give hope before it is time, then despair when they fail. Buying judiciously now will likely end well over time, but there is no hurry.
John Barnyak
President
Personally I think we still haven't seen the bottom of the market for a few reasons. Perhaps the major one being that CNBC is still on the air. Today, Nouriel Roubini opined that the S&P will see 600 by October. After a nine hundred point drop in the past eighteen months, another seventy in seven months seems like child's play. Another ten percent? Bring it on!
Considering how prescient Mr. Roubini has been in this economic debacle finding our projections relatively close seems a comforting confirmation of my own work. Below are my reasons for throwing my dart at 600.
1. I project earnings next year near $50 for the S&P 500. Goldman Sachs suggests $40 so I am not the most pessimistic.
2. Currently inflation is essentially zero.
3. Typically in a deep recession the PE ratio troughs in the high single digits however inflation impacts future earnings present value so I expect the market PE to more likely settle in the area of 12x earnings.
4. 12 times 50 is....600. Voila
It is so critical for the policy makers to get the banking system sorted out. Without that, it will remain difficult to move ahead.
What will be difficult is that bear market rallys will give hope before it is time, then despair when they fail. Buying judiciously now will likely end well over time, but there is no hurry.
John Barnyak
President
Friday, March 6, 2009
Mohammed El-Erian Video
Mohammed El-Erian describes our current challenges and a way forward. No easy answers but a good discussion.
Thursday, March 5, 2009
Things that can't happen already have
We must be near a bottom. Comedy is closer to truth than news.
http://www.thedailyshow.com/video/index.jhtml?videoId=220252
Laugh or weep...the choice is not clear.
Today the financial foundations of the U.S. economy look a little frayed.
Here’s a short list of only the highest quality, bluest of blue chip, penny stocks:
AIG (39 cents)
Citigroup (98 cents)
E*Trade (66 cents)
Fannie Mae (39 cents)
Freddie (39 cents)
Unisys (37 cents)
Given the trading volumes, you might think these were real firms or something!
Now, for the not-quite-penny stocks:
Ford ($1.83)
GM ($1.83)
Las Vegas Sands ($1.97)
MGM ($1.99)
CIT ($2)
Kodak ($2.50)
Bank of America ($3.15)
New York Times ($4.00)
News Corp ($6.15)
Xerox ($4.36)
International Paper ($4.22)
Alcoa ($5.55)
GE ($6.75)
Dow Chemical ($6.56)
Wells Fargo ($7.95)
Dell ($8.50)
It looks like American Express ($10.83) is one of the few double digit stocks . . .
John Barnyak
President
The Daily Show With Jon StewartM - Th 11p / 10c
http://www.thedailyshow.com/video/index.jhtml?videoId=220252
Laugh or weep...the choice is not clear.
Today the financial foundations of the U.S. economy look a little frayed.
Here’s a short list of only the highest quality, bluest of blue chip, penny stocks:
AIG (39 cents)
Citigroup (98 cents)
E*Trade (66 cents)
Fannie Mae (39 cents)
Freddie (39 cents)
Unisys (37 cents)
Given the trading volumes, you might think these were real firms or something!
Now, for the not-quite-penny stocks:
Ford ($1.83)
GM ($1.83)
Las Vegas Sands ($1.97)
MGM ($1.99)
CIT ($2)
Kodak ($2.50)
Bank of America ($3.15)
New York Times ($4.00)
News Corp ($6.15)
Xerox ($4.36)
International Paper ($4.22)
Alcoa ($5.55)
GE ($6.75)
Dow Chemical ($6.56)
Wells Fargo ($7.95)
Dell ($8.50)
It looks like American Express ($10.83) is one of the few double digit stocks . . .
John Barnyak
President
Tectonic Shift
The world is constantly changing. Mercifully we don't feel most of the changes. They are the incremental progressions that effect us subtly. Life changing for some, but not most. A new treatment for shingles, a breakthrough in silicon chips, a more efficient and cleaner engine. Tiny steps, quiet huge leaps that enter our lives but generally do not collide with them.
Economic and financial shifts tend to impact us more dramatically and immediately. Can we afford education, healthcare, shelter, retirement? These are in our face everyday and changes are felt quickly. Losing a job, winning the lottery, getting the tuition bill, getting ill. The global economic shifts taking place now are significant, will effect us directly and one ignores them at ones peril.
Mohamed El-Erian sees the world changing. El-Erian has been active in global finance for the past three decades. Born in New York City to an Egyptian father and French mother, he grew up both in the U.S. and abroad. He worked for the International Monetary Fund for 15 years, then did stints with Salomon Smith Barney and Pimco before running Harvard's endowment fund. He returned to Pimco, the bond powerhouse, in 2008. El-Erian is chief executive of Pimco as well as its co-chief investment officer (a title he shares with bond guru Bill Gross).
The shift is not necessarily bad for you, but it will require some adaptation. A tectonic shift is occurring. No longer will the world simply march to the U.S. rhythm. We will have to share leadership with emerging giants, such as China and India. If the US remains flexible and educated we will provide the world with goods and services easing our trade deficit and stimulating growth and jobs over time.
But stability is easy only once we get there. Transitions are hard. Vested interests struggle to keep their advantages. Just as blacksmiths and longshoremen, scribes and pick and axe coal miners pushed back against the tide so will we. Eventually the typewriter ribbon cannot be replaced, the rotary dial telephone cannot be repaired and the cassette tapes will have no place to load in the car. Imbedded thoughts do not go easily either.
Many of us are investing and saving based on rotary telephone thinking. Some of the truths that worked for a generation are now only half truths. Judging by the past several years in which so many assets we invested in moved in lockstep, diversification no longer means 60% stocks and 40% bonds. To continue in that vein will be mean having good times and bad times, but volatile times. Diversification is not dead, but the simple 60/40, buy and hold strategy will not decrease risk any longer nor will it find the dynamic opportunities.
Because of all these changes, El-Erian suggests that investors spread their money over a wider array of assets than was once thought necessary. That means shrinking U.S. stocks to smaller portion. Just 15% of your total portfolio in his view.
The world's financial landscape is being re-defined without a master plan. This has become a crisis-management phenomenon. As individuals, to attach our personal well being to global crisis management is not a strategy.
In El-Erian's world the traditional approach to diversification, "which served us very well, went like this: Adopt a diversified portfolio, be disciplined about rebalancing the asset mix, own very well-defined types of asset classes and favor the home team because the minute you invest outside the U.S., you take on additional risk. A typical mix would then be 60% stocks and 40% bonds, and most of the stocks would be part of Standard & Poor's 500-stock index.
This approach is fatigued for several reasons. First of all, diversification
alone is no longer sufficient to temper risk. In the past year, we saw virtually
every asset class hammered. You need something more to manage risk well. Second,it matters a great deal how you implement the asset allocation, because when the world gets bumpy, different investment types really do behave differently. Third, consider where we're headed. We are going toward a world where the U.S. will no longer be the most dynamic part of the global economy. Because of the debt excesses of the past few years, it will be a while before the U.S. economy returns to 3% or 4% annual growth. Therefore, the wise investor asks, "Where else can I tap into sustainable growth?" To do that, you need a more global approach. And one more thing. Don't become hostage to historical definitions of asset classes. Be flexible, because there will be opportunities that don't fit easily into those categories."
Now is the time to dig deeper, spread wings wider. We've seen what happens to the financial Icarus when soaring too close to the sun, but the wiser will still keep their wings.
John Barnyak
President
Economic and financial shifts tend to impact us more dramatically and immediately. Can we afford education, healthcare, shelter, retirement? These are in our face everyday and changes are felt quickly. Losing a job, winning the lottery, getting the tuition bill, getting ill. The global economic shifts taking place now are significant, will effect us directly and one ignores them at ones peril.
Mohamed El-Erian sees the world changing. El-Erian has been active in global finance for the past three decades. Born in New York City to an Egyptian father and French mother, he grew up both in the U.S. and abroad. He worked for the International Monetary Fund for 15 years, then did stints with Salomon Smith Barney and Pimco before running Harvard's endowment fund. He returned to Pimco, the bond powerhouse, in 2008. El-Erian is chief executive of Pimco as well as its co-chief investment officer (a title he shares with bond guru Bill Gross).
The shift is not necessarily bad for you, but it will require some adaptation. A tectonic shift is occurring. No longer will the world simply march to the U.S. rhythm. We will have to share leadership with emerging giants, such as China and India. If the US remains flexible and educated we will provide the world with goods and services easing our trade deficit and stimulating growth and jobs over time.
But stability is easy only once we get there. Transitions are hard. Vested interests struggle to keep their advantages. Just as blacksmiths and longshoremen, scribes and pick and axe coal miners pushed back against the tide so will we. Eventually the typewriter ribbon cannot be replaced, the rotary dial telephone cannot be repaired and the cassette tapes will have no place to load in the car. Imbedded thoughts do not go easily either.
Many of us are investing and saving based on rotary telephone thinking. Some of the truths that worked for a generation are now only half truths. Judging by the past several years in which so many assets we invested in moved in lockstep, diversification no longer means 60% stocks and 40% bonds. To continue in that vein will be mean having good times and bad times, but volatile times. Diversification is not dead, but the simple 60/40, buy and hold strategy will not decrease risk any longer nor will it find the dynamic opportunities.
Because of all these changes, El-Erian suggests that investors spread their money over a wider array of assets than was once thought necessary. That means shrinking U.S. stocks to smaller portion. Just 15% of your total portfolio in his view.
The world's financial landscape is being re-defined without a master plan. This has become a crisis-management phenomenon. As individuals, to attach our personal well being to global crisis management is not a strategy.
In El-Erian's world the traditional approach to diversification, "which served us very well, went like this: Adopt a diversified portfolio, be disciplined about rebalancing the asset mix, own very well-defined types of asset classes and favor the home team because the minute you invest outside the U.S., you take on additional risk. A typical mix would then be 60% stocks and 40% bonds, and most of the stocks would be part of Standard & Poor's 500-stock index.
This approach is fatigued for several reasons. First of all, diversification
alone is no longer sufficient to temper risk. In the past year, we saw virtually
every asset class hammered. You need something more to manage risk well. Second,it matters a great deal how you implement the asset allocation, because when the world gets bumpy, different investment types really do behave differently. Third, consider where we're headed. We are going toward a world where the U.S. will no longer be the most dynamic part of the global economy. Because of the debt excesses of the past few years, it will be a while before the U.S. economy returns to 3% or 4% annual growth. Therefore, the wise investor asks, "Where else can I tap into sustainable growth?" To do that, you need a more global approach. And one more thing. Don't become hostage to historical definitions of asset classes. Be flexible, because there will be opportunities that don't fit easily into those categories."
Now is the time to dig deeper, spread wings wider. We've seen what happens to the financial Icarus when soaring too close to the sun, but the wiser will still keep their wings.
John Barnyak
President
Tuesday, March 3, 2009
What is it Doctor?!
It always seemed in the sci-fi movies I watched as a kid, at some point a small group of scientists would be staring at some creature and the buxom blonde assistant would say, "what is it doctor?!" He would reply, "I don't know, I've never seen anything like it before." Not long afterwards you knew someone was going to be eaten. This grown up economic horror film is not dissimilar.
Reading the fixed income research from one of the largest investment banks today I saw that phrase again. "I've never seen anything like it." The behavior of the policy makers in Washington indicate they are also among the group peering at the creature. So the reasonable question is, who gets eaten next?
The only positive I can find is that I can find no one who is being positive. Only the VIX index show some sign of moderate complacency, which is in itself, not a good sign.
In a "normal" market condition, (i.e. those starting in 1981) the VIX showed periods of irrational fear to be "buy" signals. However those signals existed in a background of secular economic growth, but more importantly, in a period of secular bull market. Last autumn's extreme spike would normally be an all clear signal to pick up the pieces after irrational fear. However this time, the global deleveraging and credit contraction represents a very different backdrop. The economic inertia of a body in motion is proving very powerful.
The constellation of financial stars that came together to drive equities and bonds to a generation long bull market are no longer in place.
In 1980/81 the Fed Funds rate target was 18 to 20% to fight inflation. Today the target is 0 to 1/2%. The falling in interst rates made buying future earning and stocks attractive. Where do we go from zero?
There will be market dynamics in the coming years, but they will not be the same as the previous bull market. The 1000% 17 year bull market was a once in more than a century event. It may be a stretch to expect it to occur twice in a generation. Be flexible, be ready to change. Think.
John Barnyak
President
Reading the fixed income research from one of the largest investment banks today I saw that phrase again. "I've never seen anything like it." The behavior of the policy makers in Washington indicate they are also among the group peering at the creature. So the reasonable question is, who gets eaten next?
The only positive I can find is that I can find no one who is being positive. Only the VIX index show some sign of moderate complacency, which is in itself, not a good sign.
In a "normal" market condition, (i.e. those starting in 1981) the VIX showed periods of irrational fear to be "buy" signals. However those signals existed in a background of secular economic growth, but more importantly, in a period of secular bull market. Last autumn's extreme spike would normally be an all clear signal to pick up the pieces after irrational fear. However this time, the global deleveraging and credit contraction represents a very different backdrop. The economic inertia of a body in motion is proving very powerful.
The constellation of financial stars that came together to drive equities and bonds to a generation long bull market are no longer in place.
In 1980/81 the Fed Funds rate target was 18 to 20% to fight inflation. Today the target is 0 to 1/2%. The falling in interst rates made buying future earning and stocks attractive. Where do we go from zero?
There will be market dynamics in the coming years, but they will not be the same as the previous bull market. The 1000% 17 year bull market was a once in more than a century event. It may be a stretch to expect it to occur twice in a generation. Be flexible, be ready to change. Think.
John Barnyak
President
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)